“Pinoy Ako” Copied from another song ?

"As a musician who can transcribe music note for note and having an idea about technicalities, I can confidently say they are two different songs," Orange and Lemonsโ€™ vocalist and guitarist Clem Castro told Manila Bulletin via text message when asked for clarification."

more of that issue at http://www.bigbrotherph.blogspot.com/

i was able to get the lo-fidelity version of the song that was with the flash file on the putfile site (http://media.putfile.com/TheCare-Chandeliers) You can download it from here :

The_Care_Chandeliers.zipย (zip file)
The_Care_Chandeliers.mp3ย (mp3 file)



24 Responses to “Pinoy Ako” Copied from another song ?

  1. minor says:

    broken link

  2. poell says:

    its ok now.. please check…

    thanks ๐Ÿ˜‰

  3. jaja says:

    parehu nga ๐Ÿ˜ sa umpisa lang naman eh. pero yung sa chorus nde naman ehhhh ๐Ÿ˜ mas maganda yung sa owrents en lemons

  4. poell says:

    pinag aawayan kamo yan sa mga forum..

  5. Tintin says:

    Actually, IMHO, parang sa Pinoys big deal ang “magkatunog” na thingy. The same also happened to Session Road(Leaving You) and Cueshe(Stay). Actually, maraming foreign songs ang magkakatunog din(Kahit mga songs ng Nirvana at Beatles, may katunog din na songs earlier sa mga songs nila), especially if they fall in the same genre, pero people don’t make a huge fuss about it.

  6. ton2x says:

    pre hotlink ko sa blogsite ko yung mp3 files ha! salamat! link ko din site mo ok!

  7. jaja says:

    lols andaming comments heheheheheh

  8. mariah says:

    gayang gaya. hanap tayo sa mga kanta nila,, baka ginaya den. hahahhahahahahahhah! >:(

  9. edzelle says:

    okey panalo!!!

  10. arthur reyes says:

    although we may say the two are kinda same or alike. but in some ways they differ. the meaning of the piece especially..
    but the bass and beat are alike..

  11. paul memo says:

    bakit nyo sinisiraan ang.orange and lemons
    galing nga nila ehhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

  12. bemster says:

    well, well, well…ok na sana eh. Pinoy na pinoy talaga ang dating ng arange and lemon noh…gaya-gaya, pero indi naman talaga ako naniniawala na ganun ang pinoy artist, kaya lang siguro masyadong na influnce sa western music ang iba dyan.magaling naman talaga ang pinoy pero indi sa pag gaya…we have our own music culture that we need to develop and be proud of…mabuhay ang musikang pinoy!

  13. bemster says:

    orange and lemon…welcome to Iligan City! sikat na sikat dito ang original english version ng kanta nilang pinoy ako…hehehe…naiiba nga lang ang tema! it’s from the care and it’s called the chandeliers. cool song!

  14. ian_broudie says:

    I wonder where on earth did ORANGE AND LEMON got their name? but I have this XTC album entitled ORANGES AND LEMONS….hmmmmmm….di kaya?… ORIGINALITY?..pinoy nga tayo!!

  15. ian_broudie says:

    well, siguro if ORANGE AND LEMON wud change their name…why not “PONKAN AND DALANDAN” atlis that is original..PINOY NA PINOY pa ang dating!!…IPAKITA SA MUNDO KUNG ANO ANG KAYA MO!!…IPAGMALAKI MO!…dyahi yata!

  16. ian_broudie says:

    well bka naman sa susunod niyan…someting from LIGHTNING SEEDS naman ang ma kaka inspire sa kanila…aabangan ko yun!!…baka gawing THEME sa PINOY BIG BROITHER CELEBRITY namn….malay natin di ba?…

  17. ian_broudie says:

    pero sure ako..di kukuha sa WILD SWANS, kasi medyo kilala na ang WILD SWANS e…

  18. ian_broudie says:

    actually i haven’t heard other ONL songs…haven’t seen their album yet…bka merong pang familiar song doon…but..i ask you guys who already have their albums or headr their songs…worth ba? i mean pwede ba ipagmalaki?…just asking…..well bka nman yung CHANDELIERS a este yung PINOY AKO! lang nman ang may kamukha..in fairness…They’re cool musicians nma e..kasi they dig the same music i dig!!..ok lang ma inspire…hwag lang…u know what i mean..

  19. RYANiscool says:

    Wow, two song, isang beat..

    Ripoff, but I still love da song..

  20. TreeFrog says:

    Great reading you have on your blog.
    Peace Out
    TreeFrog

  21. TreeFrog says:

    Terrific Blog you have. Peace Out.
    TreeFrog

  22. JiggyWittit says:

    Kewl blog you got goin on up here.
    Peace, JiggyWittit

  23. friends4ever says:

    hindi ko marinig

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *